15 Unusual First Dance Songs That Will Make Your Wedding Stand Out

Picture of Kim Argosino
Kim Argosino
Content Writer at DJing.ca
Grooms exiting their wedding ceremony

Introduction

So, you’ve locked in the venue, the dress, and maybe even the catering (please tell me you didn’t forget the cake!). But now it’s time to make a choice that will truly define your big day: your first dance song. Sure, you could go with the usual suspects—Perfect by Ed Sheeran, anyone? 

But why not do something different, something that’ll have your guests whispering, “Wait, what song is this? I love it!” It’s time to dive into unusual first dance songs that will make your wedding stand out—and get everyone talking (in a good way).

Table of Contents

What Exactly Is an "Unusual" First Dance Song?

Glad you asked. When we talk about unusual first dance songs, we’re thinking beyond the classic wedding songs. Instead of those wedding playlist regulars, we’re diving into tracks that might not typically scream “wedding”—but when you hear them, you’ll know they’re perfect. Here’s how you can spot an unusual first dance song:

  • It’s not the obvious choice: If it’s playing at 95% of weddings you’ve attended, it’s probably not making this list.

  • Genre-bending: Most couples go with pop or ballads. What if you went with something indie, folk, rock, or jazz? How about a reggae first dance? (Okay, maybe not, but still, options!)

  • It has personal meaning: Did you both lose your minds when you heard this song for the first time? Is it “your” song, even if it doesn’t top Spotify’s wedding playlist? Go for it!

15 Unusual First Dance Songs

Now, onto the fun part: the music. Here’s a list of 15 unusual first dance songs that will give your first dance the oomph it deserves. These tracks are unconventional, but they’re packed with emotion and style. Plus, they’ll make your guests do double-takes in the best way possible.

1. "Such Great Heights" (Iron & Wine Cover)

  • Why it’s unique: This stripped-back, acoustic version of the Postal Service’s hit is raw, heartfelt, and absolutely perfect for an intimate, cozy first dance.
  • Practical Tip: Great for those who cannot dance. The slow pace makes it easier to sway, shuffle, and still look adorable.

2. "You Are the Best Thing" by Ray LaMontagne

  • Why it’s unique: Soulful and upbeat without being overplayed, this one’s for couples who can’t help but grin from ear to ear.
  • Practical Tip: Dance like no one’s watching because everyone’s probably just going to be smiling at how cute you look anyway.

3. "Harvest Moon" by Neil Young

  • Why it’s unique: Old-school cool without feeling dated, Neil Young’s track is a laid-back choice for couples who want something timeless but not overused.
  • Practical Tip: This song has a great, slow rhythm—perfect for couples with two left feet.

4. "I Found You" by Alabama Shakes

  • Why it’s unique: If you want power, passion, and some serious bluesy vibes, this is your jam.
  • Practical Tip: This one’s got a bit more energy. So if you’re planning on a little spin or a dip, here’s your moment.

5. "Ho Hey" by The Lumineers

  • Why it’s unique: Folksy and fun, this one’s for couples who want their first dance to be playful and not too serious.
  • Practical Tip: Worried about missing a step? Don’t be. This song’s casual vibe means no one’s expecting fancy moves—they’re just here for the fun.
Groom holding a glass of beer

6. "First Day of My Life" by Bright Eyes

  • Why it’s unique: Indie lovers, this one’s for you. It’s sweet, heartfelt, and oh-so-personal.
  • Practical Tip: Perfect for couples who are planning a low-key, indie vibe for their wedding. Plus, it’s easy to dance to, even if you have no rhythm.

7. "Falling Slowly" by Glen Hansard and Markéta Irglová

  • Why it’s unique: Straight out of Once, this emotionally charged ballad will give you and your guests all the feels.
  • Practical Tip: This song builds up slowly, so you can keep it simple for the first half and bust out some fancier moves as the song intensifies.

8. "I Wanna Dance with Somebody" (Acoustic Cover)

  • Why it’s unique: Whitney Houston, but make it acoustic and slow. A whole new vibe for an iconic hit.
  • Practical Tip: Be ready for some delighted looks as people recognize this classic in its new form. It’s a crowd-pleaser in disguise.

9. "Sea of Love" by Cat Power

  • Why it’s unique: Minimalist and hauntingly beautiful, this track creates an intimate moment that feels like it’s just the two of you in the room.
  • Practical Tip: This is perfect for smaller, more intimate weddings where you want to focus on each other without putting on a show.

10. "Can’t Help Falling in Love" (Kina Grannis Cover)

  • Why it’s unique: Elvis, reimagined. This softer acoustic version featured in Crazy Rich Asians is a tear-jerker.
  • Practical Tip: Grab some tissues—both for yourselves and your guests. You’ll need them.
Grooms dancing at their wedding reception

11. "Latch" (Acoustic) by Sam Smith

  • Why it’s unique: The acoustic version of this hit transforms it into a soulful love ballad that packs an emotional punch.
  • Practical Tip: If you want something modern but with a slower pace, this is your song. Plus, the lyrics are all about commitment—hello, wedding vibes!

12. "Into the Mystic" by Van Morrison

  • Why it’s unique: It’s a classic, but not in the overplayed way. Its spiritual, almost mystical feel adds something extra special to your first dance.
  • Practical Tip: This song feels timeless, and that makes it great for weddings with a vintage, boho, or classic theme.

13. "Bloom" by The Paper Kites

  • Why it’s unique: Soft, indie, and perfect for couples who want their first dance to feel personal and a little whimsical.
  • Practical Tip: This is a great choice if you want something that feels like a quiet moment shared between just the two of you—even if you’re in front of 200 people.

14. "Home" by Edward Sharpe & The Magnetic Zeros

  • Why it’s unique: Quirky, adorable, and perfect for couples who don’t take themselves too seriously.
  • Practical Tip: Consider adding some fun choreography here—it’s not too serious, so you can have a little fun with it!

15. "Toothpaste Kisses" by The Maccabees

  • Why it’s unique: Low-key and romantic, this song is a sweet indie gem that’s perfect for a relaxed, laid-back first dance.
  • Practical Tip: This is a great option if you’re both more about swaying and less about fancy footwork.

Why You Should Choose an Unusual First Dance Song

First of all, you’re not a cookie-cutter couple, so why would you pick the same song that every other couple in the world has danced to? Unusual first dance songs will do more than just surprise your guests—they’ll add a unique, personal touch to your wedding song checklist that feels authentic to you and your relationship.

Here’s why stepping outside the traditional wedding playlist is a great move:

  • Be unforgettable: Let’s face it—no one will remember which of the million couples danced to All of Me by John Legend, but they’ll definitely remember when you slow-danced to something totally unexpected. Like, say, Ho Hey by The Lumineers.

  • It’s YOU: You’re unique, quirky, and a little weird (in the best way possible), and your first dance song should reflect that. Traditional songs are great, but when you pick something unexpected, you’re showing the world your personality as a couple.

  • The “Oh My God” Effect: You want your guests to be snapping their heads toward the dance floor and grinning from ear to ear. Unusual songs can do that, leaving everyone with something to rave about after the wedding.

Let DJing.ca Rock Your Wedding!

Now that you’ve got your list of unusual first dance songs and some killer ideas to make your wedding stand out, it’s time to lock in a DJ who can deliver these tunes with flair. Trust us, the last thing you want is a wedding playlist that feels like it came straight out of your uncle’s ’90s mix CD.

That’s where DJing.ca comes in. With top-tier DJs who know how to read a room and keep the dance floor buzzing, we’ll make sure your first dance—and the rest of your night—flows perfectly. And the best part? We won’t make you break the bank! 

So, if you want a DJ who can play all your favorite tracks (yes, even those unusual first dance songs) and keep the party going, hit up DJing.ca! 🎶

Need A DJ For Your Event?

Get Quote

Continue Reading

Call NowGet a Quote

Fill Out Your Email So We can Send You The Results

You'll be notified immediately:

We’ll send you an email right away to notify you if the date is available, but in the meantime…

The #1 problem clients face...

As I’m sure you’re aware, we live in a world where people fear commitment. People leave all of their options open, because they’re afraid they might end up loosing out on a future opportunity that might be superior to what is right in front of them.

Yet this way of thinking is wrong… But why?

Because by failure to commit to something, the best options available become unavailable. What we thought was a sure thing, ends up becoming a missed opportunity. Through our deliberate action of inaction, we’re soon presented with second-tier options. Options that you wish you could’ve avoided in the first place. But you’ve already committed to the idea of hiring a DJ, so you end up going through with it anyway, and you choose whoever is available because you don’t want to completely miss out. But you know in your heart it didn’t feel like the right choice. And when the money is spent, and the performance is over, you’re disappointed. And you tell yourself: never again. Yet just like a teenager who claims to never drink again after binge drinking the night before, we end up in a cycle of never committing, and always being stuck with bad alternatives. Deep down inside, we’re unhappy. And we’re left with regret.

Amazing opportunities don't last long.

DJing.ca only performs at 125 corporate events per year,  and performs in front of companies such as McLaren, FlyOver Canada, and ActiveState. As we get more referrals each year, the number of calls & emails continues to grow. 

And with good reason.

Having a 100% satisfaction rate, we keep getting referrals. That’s what happens when you show up prepared and deliver every single time.

I know a lot of other people claim that, but here’s the facts:

We spent an entire year, or 4,000+ hours (yes, we’re work-a-holics) searching through 350 DJs, only to find the top 15 that met our expectations based on personality, experience, and professionalism. If any DJ doesn’t receive a 5/5 star rating from clients (just like yourself), they do not meet the requirements of our contract and can no longer work with us.

And here’s the kicker…

To date we haven’t had to remove anyone.

If you want your event to be truly amazing, don’t hesitate. Fill out the form, we’re here to help. Let’s work together to make your vision come to life.

Get A Quote

Typical Response Time: 75 Seconds

You're the best!

Thank You For Your Feedback

Thank you very much for working with DJing.ca and offering feedback on our service. We take your opinion very seriously, and we’re always trying to improve our service so that future clients can receive the most value possible.